Human management of freshwater has always been at the center of civilizations. Not only did most human cities emerge along rivers, but historically we remember civilizations that grew powerful because they learned to irrigate their crops better, and then to plumb their cities more effectively. At the dawn of civilization, the Sumerians emerged as dominant in their region after building extensive dams and canals to use the flood waters of the Euphrates for irrigation. The Romans, who inspired centuries of history around the Mediterranean shores, are quite possibly best remembered for their incredible aqueducts, which made farms and cities possible in deserts, and allowed hundreds of thousands of Romans to live closely together--aided by public fountains and baths, fire-extinguishing capability, complex sewers, and regular street-washing. In recent history, drilling for aquifers and channeling rivers onto dry areas permitted the rapid development of the American West, creating abundantly fertile agricultural centers in grassland/deserts like the Central Valley of California. Giant river damming projects also produced large amount of electricity, helping new cities blossom. Thus the large-scale management of western American water--damming rivers and drilling into aquifers, became in this century an idealized model for economic development around the world.
There is little doubt that the arrogation of freshwater will remain a central issue, motivating, creating, and threatening our societies into the next century as well. This is true in large part because exactly the same management practices that brought great wealth to people have often simultaneously destroyed it, just over a longer period of time. Many ecologists now agree that the deserts of the Middle East were largely created by human practices, beginning with the over-irrigation of fields. Too much water has left behind arid landscapes—because it washed away topsoil or brought salt to the fields from upstream (by gravity and evaporation) or from deeper ground (by osmosis). Despite huge aqueducts, the Mediterranean fields that once propelled the Roman Empire grew less productive and then insufficient, contributing to the Empire's relocation east to Byzantium(1). In recent history much of the last century's growth in population, in the U.S. and the developing world, has been dependent on unsustainable water sources, making billions of people alarmingly dependent on falling aquifers and dwindling rivers. Many mechanized farming practices and the careless paving involved in rapid urbanization are both accelerating the trend toward desertification (2).
At its worst water scarcity and misuse is expected to lead to war. Both the United Nations and the CIA have predicted future wars over water. Former UN Secretary General Boutrous Boutrous Ghali has predicted that the next war in his region will be over the Nile. In the last fifty years Egypt has already sent troops into both Sudan and Ethiopia to protect the headwaters of the Nile, and the population of that region is expected to double. A primary Israeli motive in the Six-Day War was to secure its water supply by conquering the Golan Heights from Syria. Today, as millions more Israelis are recruited into the country, and as Jordanians and Palestinians swell their own populations, the water they must share, from the Sea of Galilee down the Jordan River, is diminishing. In southern India a long-standing dispute between the upstream city of Karnataka and the downsream city of Tamil Nadu has lead to riots and fighting in the streets (3). While water tables, in places from China to South Africa to the American Midwest, fall from overpumping, and an increasing number of rivers, from the Yellow to the Ganges to the Colorado, fail to reach the ocean at certain times of year, the proportion of people without access to clean water is over 20%, while the number without proper sanitation sewers is over 30% (2). Water shortages and its effects are arguably much more urgent than the fossil fuel shortages that have received so much more attention in the
U.S..
In countries that can afford it, water scarcities can be dealt with by importing water, especially the more economical "virtual imports" of water. One ton of grain is roughly equivalent to 1000 tons of water, and one ton of beef can require more than fifty times that. So, when the water tables of northern China collapse below the minimum level, as they are expected to in the upcoming years, and the farmers are unable to grow as much food, the extra demand on the international grain market will likely cause a sudden increase in price. After watching Chinese demand increase the international price of commodities like oil and copper, it is less difficult to imagine a sharp increase in the price of grain (4).
Even in places where water scarcities are less imminent, big changes are in the works. World Bank loans in the developing world are increasingly contingent on privatizing water utilities. States and cities in the U.S. unable to find the money to fix the aging infrastructure of their water works are beginning to look more favorably on privatization schemes. Between 1990 and 2002 the number of people receiving tap water from private companies increased from approximately 50 million to 300 million. Water has long been the domain of governments -- some argue that large-scale water management was the historic motivation for big governments in the first place. So as private corporations move into this turf, the battle will likely be contentious. Citizens of Cochabamba, Bolivia already rioted after an American consortium bought full rights to a region's water, even including personal wells, and then raised the price up to 150% (5).
All these threats create a situation where water conservation and re-use make more sense than provisioning more water. Compared to the costs of proposed desalination projects, water pipelines and tankers, increased food prices, and military budgets, the cost of water efficiency is much more affordable. And there are several obvious methods to avoid waste. Drip-irrigation, with water placed precisely where and when crops need it, can increase agricultural yields with half as much water. Eating plant calories rather than meat calories, as alluded to earlier, can be 50,000 times more water-efficient. Choosing native vegetation for landscaping can completely eliminate artificial watering. Collecting and using the rainwater that falls on the roof can simultaneously reduce the burden on stormwater systems while providing surprising quantities of the freshest kind of water. Using purified water only for drinking and washing, then reusing the resultant gray-water for toilets, and then reusing toilet water for landscapes are simple ways to get more out of a smaller amount of water. With such techniques households in many parts of the world can become independent of water delivery pipes (6).
As desertification becomes a more obvious problem, related to loss of agriculture, habitat, and species, poisonous dust storms, and depleted ecosystem services like weather stability, it makes sense to make water plans on a larger scale. Digging extensive swales and terraces, and nurturing vegetation in certain dry areas can increase the amount of rain water held in the soil. With more water in the ground, more rain can evaporate to areas further from the ocean, with the possibility of shrinking deserts, greening the land, protecting species, and even increasing the total biomass of life (7).
How we decide to manage fresh water into the future may define our civilization even more than it has in the past. The natural political relationship between those upstream and downstream will become more obvious, and may even re-orient political domains from national boundaries (based more on languages and strategic military factors) to watersheds. How we answer questions about who owns water and how much the poorest should pay for it will define how members of our society relate to each other in a fundamental way. Our ability to learn from long-term, ancient mistakes with water management may even allow our civilization to transcend itself and become one that reverses the drying up of Earth. Instead of causing erosion, salting, and siltation, instead of being a people who drain wetlands, we can become people who reverse erosion and thicken moist soils, refill wetlands, and water the desert.
But the optimistic forecasts are not inevitable. Or, rather, people may not shift towards more intelligent management before leaving a stain of deaths and wars in our memory. Minimizing this kind of priceless cost will take more people thinking more broadly about water planning, and then communicating better ideas with each other. The rapidity and depth of this project will be historically significant.
1. Ponting, Clive. A Green History of the World. Penguin 1993. pp. 68-88
2. Brown, Lester, and Brian Halweil. "Population Outrunning Water
Supply" Worldwatch Institute Press Release. Sept. 23, 1999
3. Gleick, Peter. "Water Conflict Chronology."
www.worldwater.org/conflict . August 18, 2003
4. Brown, Lester, and Brian Halweil. "China's Water Shortage Could
Shake World Water Markets." Worldwatch Press Release. April 22, 1998
5. Marsden, Bill. "Cholera and the Water Barons." The Center for
Public Integrity. August 2004
6. Hawken, Paul, Amory Lovins, and Hunter Lovins. Natural Capitalism.
Little, Brown and Company. 1999 pp. 213-233
7. Mollison, Bill. Permaculture. Tagari 1988. pp 308-410
Wednesday, February 23, 2005
the grace of flowering plants
the grace of flowering plants
Pushing aside forests of cycads and conifers and overgrowing vast fern groves, the angiosperms impressively bloomed across the land about 100 million years ago. Dominating the lands, except where the conifers found refuge up the slopes and away from the Equator, these flowering plants proliferated rapidly as the Mesozoic Era ended, and they continued to diversify during the Cenozoic. Today angiosperms are by far the most dominant, diverse, and recently unique of plant varieties; they are the homes and the source for most of the world's animals.
Before angiosperms, there had been only plants without flowers. The ground had been dominated by mosses and ferns, then forests of palm tree-esque cycads, then forests of coney conifer trees. The advent of angiosperms was dramatic. Today they are the grasses and flowers and fruit-producing trees, most of the shrubs, most of the tropical trees, and almost every kind of deciduous tree. Angiosperms have shaped this age of life on Earth in all but the most plate-tectonically large ways.
About a hundred-forty million years ago, as the single Pangaean continent was splitting south into Gondwanaland and north into Laurasia, a single angiosperm emerged as a new variety of plant. It may have been in what we call China today, but Austalia and Portugal also contain fossils of these early ancestors. The first flowers evolved from leaves and were probably green, the first red fruits evolved around the seed. These early angiosperms were small herbaceous plants adapted to disrupted ecosystems, and after developing through about 40 million seasons around the Sun, they became rapidly more abundant and diverse.
Old Gondwanaland was the location for most of this blossoming. In the Rift Valley between modern Africa and South America, in lower altitudes, perhaps where ocean flooding had killed off the old conifer forests, the angiosperms productively inhabited their niche. Plants had first learned to spread pollen by water, then they learned to spread in wind; the angiosperm began to spread by using the existing flying and eating patterns of insects. Going between similar trees, these insects began to carry pollen on their backs.
More accurately pollinating each other, the angiosperms also produced seeds faster than other plants -- more than once a year. They reproduced fast. These seeds were also double-fertilized, by two sperms, and one offspring was a fruity encasing, which -- by fruit! -- gave angiosperms the fertile range of animals. Thicker plants began to cover more areas, holding more nutrients, more biomass, and more water in the soil. By about 90 million years ago, so quickly that Darwin called their rapid emergence in the fossil record "an abominable mystery," angiosperms came to dominate the land. After about 65 million years ago, the thickest angiosperm forests achieved a closed canopy.
While they drove aside the cycads, conifers, and ferns, expediting the extinction of many old types of plant, the angiosperms also increased both the total mass of life and the total number of Earth's reproducing species. Interactions with the insects and animals became more specific and subtle: by 55 million years ago, the plants had become sophisticated with colors, smells, and nectars, new varieties of organic chemicals intended for both bribe and defense. Today flies like flowers with traps or smells of decay; the bees like the sweet fragrances and yellow, blue, and white petals; while birds and mammals prefer the reddish colors and only a little odor.
The angiosperms diversified the species of certain families of insect -- the first ants and butterflies, termites, grasshoppers, and aphids emerged -- insects who found niches in specific flowers, branches, trunks, and soil spaces. Angiosperms diversified the dinosaurs, doubling the number of species just before the dinosaurs' extinction and proflierating their only surving ancestors - birds. The angiosperms diversified mammals -- shaping tree-crawlers and climbers, swingers, and fliers -- mammals who ate the swollen populations of insects, and partook directly in the new nectars and fruits.
As the climate cooled and dried about 30 million years ago, some angiosperms reached out to cover the the vast stretches of land left by receding forests: the grasses evolved. Again they covered new terrain, inhabited disrupted areas faster, and produced new sources of food.
From the trees, big grazing mammals evolved onto the grasslands. Predators soon followed. Living at the edge of the forest and grassland, a group of primates began to manifest in human-like forms. They were hunters and gatherers, and by 200,000 years ago one strain became humans.
By 50,000 years ago, people moved from Africa and discovered ever-more of the angiosperms' bounty. Grasses provided the wheat, barley, millet, rice, oats, and corn as people became grain-raisers north of the equator after about 10,000 years ago. The legume family provided the beans and peas. The rose family produced plums, peaches, pears, strawberries, loquats, cherries, nectarines, apricots, raspberries, blackberries, and almonds.
People found new fruits in plants around the world. They found that a burst of creativity (about 4 million years ago) on the land somewhere between modern Kazakstan and China produced a bountiful diversity of apples. The first citrus ancestors of oranges came into color on an everygreen tree in the area around Malaysia (about 20 million years ago).
The angiosperm plants have always been our primary sustenance -- we could not exist if they had not preceded us. Photosynthesis by angiosperms provides the food calories for our lives, with almost no exceptions. Ecosystems rooted with angiosperms have until recently comprised most of the components of our habitat. They are our nourishment, home, medicine, and even inspiration.
The beauty of a tomato fruit shaped by humans from the vines of Peru inspired this writing.
Corn and rice fruits from stalks of the grass family, beans and peanuts from the soil-restoring legume family, broccoli from the old mustard family grapes, from the vines of Mediterranean western Asia, and nectar collected from clover flowers by bees, these flowers and fruits nourished this writing.
And for perhaps a third of the paper of this magazine -- all the hardwoods -- we have the angiosperms to thank. Colorful, fragrant, sweet, and inherently sexy -- fast-spreading trees, the makings for us -- thank you.
Pushing aside forests of cycads and conifers and overgrowing vast fern groves, the angiosperms impressively bloomed across the land about 100 million years ago. Dominating the lands, except where the conifers found refuge up the slopes and away from the Equator, these flowering plants proliferated rapidly as the Mesozoic Era ended, and they continued to diversify during the Cenozoic. Today angiosperms are by far the most dominant, diverse, and recently unique of plant varieties; they are the homes and the source for most of the world's animals.
Before angiosperms, there had been only plants without flowers. The ground had been dominated by mosses and ferns, then forests of palm tree-esque cycads, then forests of coney conifer trees. The advent of angiosperms was dramatic. Today they are the grasses and flowers and fruit-producing trees, most of the shrubs, most of the tropical trees, and almost every kind of deciduous tree. Angiosperms have shaped this age of life on Earth in all but the most plate-tectonically large ways.
About a hundred-forty million years ago, as the single Pangaean continent was splitting south into Gondwanaland and north into Laurasia, a single angiosperm emerged as a new variety of plant. It may have been in what we call China today, but Austalia and Portugal also contain fossils of these early ancestors. The first flowers evolved from leaves and were probably green, the first red fruits evolved around the seed. These early angiosperms were small herbaceous plants adapted to disrupted ecosystems, and after developing through about 40 million seasons around the Sun, they became rapidly more abundant and diverse.
Old Gondwanaland was the location for most of this blossoming. In the Rift Valley between modern Africa and South America, in lower altitudes, perhaps where ocean flooding had killed off the old conifer forests, the angiosperms productively inhabited their niche. Plants had first learned to spread pollen by water, then they learned to spread in wind; the angiosperm began to spread by using the existing flying and eating patterns of insects. Going between similar trees, these insects began to carry pollen on their backs.
More accurately pollinating each other, the angiosperms also produced seeds faster than other plants -- more than once a year. They reproduced fast. These seeds were also double-fertilized, by two sperms, and one offspring was a fruity encasing, which -- by fruit! -- gave angiosperms the fertile range of animals. Thicker plants began to cover more areas, holding more nutrients, more biomass, and more water in the soil. By about 90 million years ago, so quickly that Darwin called their rapid emergence in the fossil record "an abominable mystery," angiosperms came to dominate the land. After about 65 million years ago, the thickest angiosperm forests achieved a closed canopy.
While they drove aside the cycads, conifers, and ferns, expediting the extinction of many old types of plant, the angiosperms also increased both the total mass of life and the total number of Earth's reproducing species. Interactions with the insects and animals became more specific and subtle: by 55 million years ago, the plants had become sophisticated with colors, smells, and nectars, new varieties of organic chemicals intended for both bribe and defense. Today flies like flowers with traps or smells of decay; the bees like the sweet fragrances and yellow, blue, and white petals; while birds and mammals prefer the reddish colors and only a little odor.
The angiosperms diversified the species of certain families of insect -- the first ants and butterflies, termites, grasshoppers, and aphids emerged -- insects who found niches in specific flowers, branches, trunks, and soil spaces. Angiosperms diversified the dinosaurs, doubling the number of species just before the dinosaurs' extinction and proflierating their only surving ancestors - birds. The angiosperms diversified mammals -- shaping tree-crawlers and climbers, swingers, and fliers -- mammals who ate the swollen populations of insects, and partook directly in the new nectars and fruits.
As the climate cooled and dried about 30 million years ago, some angiosperms reached out to cover the the vast stretches of land left by receding forests: the grasses evolved. Again they covered new terrain, inhabited disrupted areas faster, and produced new sources of food.
From the trees, big grazing mammals evolved onto the grasslands. Predators soon followed. Living at the edge of the forest and grassland, a group of primates began to manifest in human-like forms. They were hunters and gatherers, and by 200,000 years ago one strain became humans.
By 50,000 years ago, people moved from Africa and discovered ever-more of the angiosperms' bounty. Grasses provided the wheat, barley, millet, rice, oats, and corn as people became grain-raisers north of the equator after about 10,000 years ago. The legume family provided the beans and peas. The rose family produced plums, peaches, pears, strawberries, loquats, cherries, nectarines, apricots, raspberries, blackberries, and almonds.
People found new fruits in plants around the world. They found that a burst of creativity (about 4 million years ago) on the land somewhere between modern Kazakstan and China produced a bountiful diversity of apples. The first citrus ancestors of oranges came into color on an everygreen tree in the area around Malaysia (about 20 million years ago).
The angiosperm plants have always been our primary sustenance -- we could not exist if they had not preceded us. Photosynthesis by angiosperms provides the food calories for our lives, with almost no exceptions. Ecosystems rooted with angiosperms have until recently comprised most of the components of our habitat. They are our nourishment, home, medicine, and even inspiration.
The beauty of a tomato fruit shaped by humans from the vines of Peru inspired this writing.
Corn and rice fruits from stalks of the grass family, beans and peanuts from the soil-restoring legume family, broccoli from the old mustard family grapes, from the vines of Mediterranean western Asia, and nectar collected from clover flowers by bees, these flowers and fruits nourished this writing.
And for perhaps a third of the paper of this magazine -- all the hardwoods -- we have the angiosperms to thank. Colorful, fragrant, sweet, and inherently sexy -- fast-spreading trees, the makings for us -- thank you.
Tuesday, February 01, 2005
becoming the web
I'm trying to filter out the good stuff for you.
Send me what you think, too.
Intelligently webbing good memes, we're at a new level.
memefilter@gmail.com
Send me what you think, too.
Intelligently webbing good memes, we're at a new level.
memefilter@gmail.com
Tuesday, January 22, 2002
Being the Music
Being the Music
January 22, 2002
By Peter Stair
From dreaming, I wake up. The sun touches me. I feel energized. I breathe the trees. I feel at home. I drink some cool water. From dry and stale, I become lubricated and refreshed.
I pace myself. Not too much movement. Not ready to breathe heavily yet. Not too much sound. Still listening to silent dreams. Too much of almost anything and I will become grumpy.
So: slow, please, I’m tuning up. I’m going to make music today.
I pace myself. I walk. Stretching out, loosening up. From dream to ground. To left from right. I’m finding the rhythm. I find it . . .
. . . and I begin gliding. From discrete steps to a continuous flow.
I notice more rhythms around me. The rocking of the trees. The zig-zag of an insect. The rapid hum of a machine. The whish of a car. The bouncing of molecules against my skin (a slow beat means “cold”) The frequencies of the sky. These are the vibrations that comprise the world of my perception. Today I find a harmonic collection. This part of the country makes some beautiful music!
Class. My professor speaks, emphasizing and pausing in clarifying ways. He is singing. I temporarily don’t understand his harmony. I sing my own version of what he’s saying, but I end with an up-note, as if I’m waiting completion. I am a question mark: raised shoulders, raised eyebrows, leaning forward. I’m waiting for him to bring us back down from my up note and eventually back to the tonic home note. When he does, I get a subtle rush of relief, and I nod with a rhythm and depth that says, “Thank you. I understand.” He ends the lecture on a concluding down note. We close our notebooks in applause.
I walk through a briar patch of other people walking and biking, each at different angles, speeds and awarenesses. If one person were to direct all of our movements, many of us would crash, or not move as quickly. But, when we feel each other, the most effective thing is anarchy. If we expect the other person to change their direction and speed too much, or if we change our own rhythm too unpredictably, we struggle with each other, and we become trapped in the briar patch. Today, we don’t dodge. We harmonize.
I stop to talk with a friend. She is beautiful. We make music. I say something brief. She says something longer, in her higher octave. I say something brief again. She says something brief. I listen to her, I see her, I smell her. I feel the melody of our conversation. Another friend gracefully enters and pipes in. We more than look at each others’ eyes.
I walk back to my home — returning my music to a tonic note. I eat. One bite at a time. I chew, one chomp after another. I drink, one sip, then another. I become a rhythm.
I am a permanent flow. Within a couple weeks, I will have entirely rebuilt my skin. Within about two months I will remake my red blood cells. A few years from now, I will finish completely reconstituting my bones. Within a few more years, I will have replaced the molecules that make up my DNA. I will eventually breathe, sweat, poop and pee the contents of my body.
I am simply the information that directs this flow. I am the score.
Between the “in” and the “out” is the energy that is me. Thinking, talking, smelling, smiling. In between are the movements that comprise my day. These movements are the dance of my life.
The day is getting warmer, and my pace is getting faster. I decide to rush to class because I want to finish composing an e-mail, and I think I will enjoy the rushing of wind in my face and of blood in my muscles and gliding on my bike and humming fast music . . . and then sliding, panting, into the classroom.
I do this, and I enjoy it. There’s something profound about myself that I don’t really understand, but it’s also something I’m willing to accept without thinking much: being alive feels good.
Today I will learn to be more alive. I read, and I learn. I talk with other people, and I learn. I watch other people interact, and I learn. I feel my body, my little sorenesses and sadnesses, and I learn what I can avoid doing again. I will learn to be less stagnant, more alive.
The discussion section I attend is an opportunity to improvise. I have the ability to speak at any moment, but I choose to speak when certain cues are right. I can let my TA finish, or if it makes better music, I can interrupt her when I don’t understand. I can walk out anytime, but I leave to go to the bathroom at a certain moment, and with a certain, more harmonious body language.
Every moment is another opportunity for me to improvise. More than other organisms or natural processes, I have the ability to change my melody rapidly. Like a vocalist or a soloist in an orchestra, I have leeway. The sun, the plants, the insects create the beat and underscore that allows me to do some interesting things on top. I can do a hand-stand right now. I can stop breathing for a few moments. I can sit over there instead of here. It’s not all instinct.
It’s especially interesting how I play music with other humans. How well do we support each other? We spontaneously create a soccer game before dinner. We talk sporadically, harmonizing our desires to listen, speak and move.
But! I fail to pass the soccer ball where I wanted it to go — I’m off-pitch. I interrupt someone in a disruptive way — I’m off-pace. I continue to eat more chocolate chips than I feel good eating — I’m a broken record. I can easily make bad music.
So, feeling sluggish, I clean out my filters by exercising. I rush blood, sweat, air and heat through my pipes. I stretch, loosen and become a clearer vessel. Now I feel more like smiling to the stranger I pass.
I shower off my exterior, feeling far from stagnant.
I reorder my room, reducing the dissonance of the pathway across it.
I prepare sleep. But I play slow music on my computer before I get into bed.
Sleep is the long, deep tonic note that I must always, and will ultimately, return to. From movement to rest. Tension and release is the repeating story of the universe. What a day I’ve had!
I dream, as usual, of a double helix. From what angle do I see it tonight? It is a circular / linear, unified / binary, yin / yang universe I live in.
From dreaming, I wake up.
The sun’s excess touches me. I feel energized. I breathe the trees’ extras. I feel at home.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. If you read his column last week (available at The Daily’s Web site) you would understand what he means when he says he’s schizophrenic. He’s never written a column, or anything, quite like this. Will it sound “on” or “off” pitch to others? E-mail him at pstair@stanford.edu.
January 22, 2002
By Peter Stair
From dreaming, I wake up. The sun touches me. I feel energized. I breathe the trees. I feel at home. I drink some cool water. From dry and stale, I become lubricated and refreshed.
I pace myself. Not too much movement. Not ready to breathe heavily yet. Not too much sound. Still listening to silent dreams. Too much of almost anything and I will become grumpy.
So: slow, please, I’m tuning up. I’m going to make music today.
I pace myself. I walk. Stretching out, loosening up. From dream to ground. To left from right. I’m finding the rhythm. I find it . . .
. . . and I begin gliding. From discrete steps to a continuous flow.
I notice more rhythms around me. The rocking of the trees. The zig-zag of an insect. The rapid hum of a machine. The whish of a car. The bouncing of molecules against my skin (a slow beat means “cold”) The frequencies of the sky. These are the vibrations that comprise the world of my perception. Today I find a harmonic collection. This part of the country makes some beautiful music!
Class. My professor speaks, emphasizing and pausing in clarifying ways. He is singing. I temporarily don’t understand his harmony. I sing my own version of what he’s saying, but I end with an up-note, as if I’m waiting completion. I am a question mark: raised shoulders, raised eyebrows, leaning forward. I’m waiting for him to bring us back down from my up note and eventually back to the tonic home note. When he does, I get a subtle rush of relief, and I nod with a rhythm and depth that says, “Thank you. I understand.” He ends the lecture on a concluding down note. We close our notebooks in applause.
I walk through a briar patch of other people walking and biking, each at different angles, speeds and awarenesses. If one person were to direct all of our movements, many of us would crash, or not move as quickly. But, when we feel each other, the most effective thing is anarchy. If we expect the other person to change their direction and speed too much, or if we change our own rhythm too unpredictably, we struggle with each other, and we become trapped in the briar patch. Today, we don’t dodge. We harmonize.
I stop to talk with a friend. She is beautiful. We make music. I say something brief. She says something longer, in her higher octave. I say something brief again. She says something brief. I listen to her, I see her, I smell her. I feel the melody of our conversation. Another friend gracefully enters and pipes in. We more than look at each others’ eyes.
I walk back to my home — returning my music to a tonic note. I eat. One bite at a time. I chew, one chomp after another. I drink, one sip, then another. I become a rhythm.
I am a permanent flow. Within a couple weeks, I will have entirely rebuilt my skin. Within about two months I will remake my red blood cells. A few years from now, I will finish completely reconstituting my bones. Within a few more years, I will have replaced the molecules that make up my DNA. I will eventually breathe, sweat, poop and pee the contents of my body.
I am simply the information that directs this flow. I am the score.
Between the “in” and the “out” is the energy that is me. Thinking, talking, smelling, smiling. In between are the movements that comprise my day. These movements are the dance of my life.
The day is getting warmer, and my pace is getting faster. I decide to rush to class because I want to finish composing an e-mail, and I think I will enjoy the rushing of wind in my face and of blood in my muscles and gliding on my bike and humming fast music . . . and then sliding, panting, into the classroom.
I do this, and I enjoy it. There’s something profound about myself that I don’t really understand, but it’s also something I’m willing to accept without thinking much: being alive feels good.
Today I will learn to be more alive. I read, and I learn. I talk with other people, and I learn. I watch other people interact, and I learn. I feel my body, my little sorenesses and sadnesses, and I learn what I can avoid doing again. I will learn to be less stagnant, more alive.
The discussion section I attend is an opportunity to improvise. I have the ability to speak at any moment, but I choose to speak when certain cues are right. I can let my TA finish, or if it makes better music, I can interrupt her when I don’t understand. I can walk out anytime, but I leave to go to the bathroom at a certain moment, and with a certain, more harmonious body language.
Every moment is another opportunity for me to improvise. More than other organisms or natural processes, I have the ability to change my melody rapidly. Like a vocalist or a soloist in an orchestra, I have leeway. The sun, the plants, the insects create the beat and underscore that allows me to do some interesting things on top. I can do a hand-stand right now. I can stop breathing for a few moments. I can sit over there instead of here. It’s not all instinct.
It’s especially interesting how I play music with other humans. How well do we support each other? We spontaneously create a soccer game before dinner. We talk sporadically, harmonizing our desires to listen, speak and move.
But! I fail to pass the soccer ball where I wanted it to go — I’m off-pitch. I interrupt someone in a disruptive way — I’m off-pace. I continue to eat more chocolate chips than I feel good eating — I’m a broken record. I can easily make bad music.
So, feeling sluggish, I clean out my filters by exercising. I rush blood, sweat, air and heat through my pipes. I stretch, loosen and become a clearer vessel. Now I feel more like smiling to the stranger I pass.
I shower off my exterior, feeling far from stagnant.
I reorder my room, reducing the dissonance of the pathway across it.
I prepare sleep. But I play slow music on my computer before I get into bed.
Sleep is the long, deep tonic note that I must always, and will ultimately, return to. From movement to rest. Tension and release is the repeating story of the universe. What a day I’ve had!
I dream, as usual, of a double helix. From what angle do I see it tonight? It is a circular / linear, unified / binary, yin / yang universe I live in.
From dreaming, I wake up.
The sun’s excess touches me. I feel energized. I breathe the trees’ extras. I feel at home.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. If you read his column last week (available at The Daily’s Web site) you would understand what he means when he says he’s schizophrenic. He’s never written a column, or anything, quite like this. Will it sound “on” or “off” pitch to others? E-mail him at pstair@stanford.edu.
Tuesday, January 15, 2002
Time, Life, Acceling
Time, Life, Acceling
January 15, 2002
By Peter Stair
I wake up this morning and have only five minutes to get where I’m going, so I don’t want to be where I am.
I throw off the covers of my nicely warmed bed and throw my notebooks into my bag, which I toss over my shoulder, and then jump onto my bike and race to class. I sit down in class just after the professor starts and settle down from my momentary frenzy. I slept only six hours last night.
So my head nods as the teacher drones about some new set of observations and connections humans made not long ago. He’s pretty excited about all the stuff we’re learning so quickly in his field these days. He makes a joke about an ignorant conception of the world that people used to have, and I’m temporarily jolted out of my daze. I don’t get the joke, because I haven’t been paying attention, and I didn’t have time to drink my coffee this morning, so I’m too slow for him. I’m not going to understand much today, so I just want to get through this class. So, when I hear the professor wrapping up, I start packing up, and the professor is like, “one more minute,” but I’ve already decided that he’s finished, and when he does stop speaking I’m the third person out of the room. “Hi,” I nod to someone I know from my freshman dorm. We haven’t actually stopped to talk all quarter.
So I’m on my bike again and I’m going to my next class, which is far away and was scheduled so that I have only seven minutes to get there, and I don’t recognize anyone I know until it’s too late to say, “hi.” I get upset with the slow walkers spread out in front of me and at the guy who’s recklessly weaving around people on his bike. And I just don’t understand why other people have to be such a problem.
So I get to my next class, and I snatch a seat. It’s another class that’s only mildly interesting. This is one of those classes where I really respect the professor, but I don’t have time to do all the reading. I think I miss a lot.
I sometimes think about living on campus without all the deadlines and pressures. I could just learn what I want to learn, hang out with friends, go skiing and visit all the other interesting places in this area. But I really shouldn’t be upset by my life. This is the best time of my life, after all. I think I like it here. I like it. Actually, I know I like it. A lot.
The professor finishes, and I jump back on my bike and go back to my dorm, but I forget to stop by the Bookstore to buy new batteries for my alarm clock, and so I rush back to get them. But I can’t stand lines, even though I have to.
I know that I’m going to be late to lunch with an old friend I haven’t seen in a while. Luckily I know she will be late also. We grab food and talk to each other. I’m so impressed by how busy she’s been.
But she has to rush off to a meeting, and I have to go to another class. So we agree to meet again sometime.
After class, I bike back to my room. I haven’t checked e-mail all day! But it’s just announcements for events I don’t have time to go to. I start catching up on my reading, but I realize that I need to exercise. The gym is crowded, and my favorite machine is broken, so I try out a new and unfamiliar machine. It feels strange, but, hey, change is good. Then I notice that I have only 45 minutes before dinner, so I try to work extra hard, even on my strange machine.
I make it back to dinner in time to get some of the good food! But I don’t stay for long, because I need to do some reading. But it’s hard to stick with, even though it’s about dinosaurs and a meteor and the scramble to survive. I’m not understanding it.
So I check e-mail again and get a really long and thoughtful e-mail from a friend on the East Coast. But it’s too good: I don’t have the time to respond properly right now. I really like this friend.
So my attention wanders, and I pick up my stuffed dinosaur. Here’s one that didn’t go extinct, I think cleverly. But he doesn’t look like a survivor at all. He’s goofy-looking and soft, and he looks like he’d be really slow. And, though I’ve only had him for a little while, I’ve used him enough that he’s already old and I should get a new one. But — ahhh — what am I doing? I don’t have time for this.
I do the reading for another class, but I don’t do as much as I need to. I start responding to my friend’s e-mail, but I don’t want to send him a 20 page e-mail, so I have to think about what I want to say. I’ll finish it later.
I continue my reading. I’m catching up. I think this is progress!
I decide I’m going to go to bed a little bit earlier than usual today. So I move some piles around in my room, and get into bed. Another day over. But I start thinking about all the things I still have to do, like that application, and solidifying my plans for spring break, and deciding what I’m going to do this summer, and getting my brother a birthday present, and I’m still way behind on reading. Damn! I didn’t do anything today.
I’m sick and tired of doing so much, I think. But it’s not that bad. I like being busy. I think I might be getting a little sick. Hopefully just a little, though, because I don’t have the time to be sick. I’m sick of being sick.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. He wants to pay tribute to Jorge Luis Borges for his brief profundity, and likes the movie “Koyanisquatsi” (“out of balance”). “Make Haste or you will become Waste,” his grandfather always told him, or something like that. He likes when people take the time to send him comments at pstair@stanford.edu.
January 15, 2002
By Peter Stair
I wake up this morning and have only five minutes to get where I’m going, so I don’t want to be where I am.
I throw off the covers of my nicely warmed bed and throw my notebooks into my bag, which I toss over my shoulder, and then jump onto my bike and race to class. I sit down in class just after the professor starts and settle down from my momentary frenzy. I slept only six hours last night.
So my head nods as the teacher drones about some new set of observations and connections humans made not long ago. He’s pretty excited about all the stuff we’re learning so quickly in his field these days. He makes a joke about an ignorant conception of the world that people used to have, and I’m temporarily jolted out of my daze. I don’t get the joke, because I haven’t been paying attention, and I didn’t have time to drink my coffee this morning, so I’m too slow for him. I’m not going to understand much today, so I just want to get through this class. So, when I hear the professor wrapping up, I start packing up, and the professor is like, “one more minute,” but I’ve already decided that he’s finished, and when he does stop speaking I’m the third person out of the room. “Hi,” I nod to someone I know from my freshman dorm. We haven’t actually stopped to talk all quarter.
So I’m on my bike again and I’m going to my next class, which is far away and was scheduled so that I have only seven minutes to get there, and I don’t recognize anyone I know until it’s too late to say, “hi.” I get upset with the slow walkers spread out in front of me and at the guy who’s recklessly weaving around people on his bike. And I just don’t understand why other people have to be such a problem.
So I get to my next class, and I snatch a seat. It’s another class that’s only mildly interesting. This is one of those classes where I really respect the professor, but I don’t have time to do all the reading. I think I miss a lot.
I sometimes think about living on campus without all the deadlines and pressures. I could just learn what I want to learn, hang out with friends, go skiing and visit all the other interesting places in this area. But I really shouldn’t be upset by my life. This is the best time of my life, after all. I think I like it here. I like it. Actually, I know I like it. A lot.
The professor finishes, and I jump back on my bike and go back to my dorm, but I forget to stop by the Bookstore to buy new batteries for my alarm clock, and so I rush back to get them. But I can’t stand lines, even though I have to.
I know that I’m going to be late to lunch with an old friend I haven’t seen in a while. Luckily I know she will be late also. We grab food and talk to each other. I’m so impressed by how busy she’s been.
But she has to rush off to a meeting, and I have to go to another class. So we agree to meet again sometime.
After class, I bike back to my room. I haven’t checked e-mail all day! But it’s just announcements for events I don’t have time to go to. I start catching up on my reading, but I realize that I need to exercise. The gym is crowded, and my favorite machine is broken, so I try out a new and unfamiliar machine. It feels strange, but, hey, change is good. Then I notice that I have only 45 minutes before dinner, so I try to work extra hard, even on my strange machine.
I make it back to dinner in time to get some of the good food! But I don’t stay for long, because I need to do some reading. But it’s hard to stick with, even though it’s about dinosaurs and a meteor and the scramble to survive. I’m not understanding it.
So I check e-mail again and get a really long and thoughtful e-mail from a friend on the East Coast. But it’s too good: I don’t have the time to respond properly right now. I really like this friend.
So my attention wanders, and I pick up my stuffed dinosaur. Here’s one that didn’t go extinct, I think cleverly. But he doesn’t look like a survivor at all. He’s goofy-looking and soft, and he looks like he’d be really slow. And, though I’ve only had him for a little while, I’ve used him enough that he’s already old and I should get a new one. But — ahhh — what am I doing? I don’t have time for this.
I do the reading for another class, but I don’t do as much as I need to. I start responding to my friend’s e-mail, but I don’t want to send him a 20 page e-mail, so I have to think about what I want to say. I’ll finish it later.
I continue my reading. I’m catching up. I think this is progress!
I decide I’m going to go to bed a little bit earlier than usual today. So I move some piles around in my room, and get into bed. Another day over. But I start thinking about all the things I still have to do, like that application, and solidifying my plans for spring break, and deciding what I’m going to do this summer, and getting my brother a birthday present, and I’m still way behind on reading. Damn! I didn’t do anything today.
I’m sick and tired of doing so much, I think. But it’s not that bad. I like being busy. I think I might be getting a little sick. Hopefully just a little, though, because I don’t have the time to be sick. I’m sick of being sick.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. He wants to pay tribute to Jorge Luis Borges for his brief profundity, and likes the movie “Koyanisquatsi” (“out of balance”). “Make Haste or you will become Waste,” his grandfather always told him, or something like that. He likes when people take the time to send him comments at pstair@stanford.edu.
Tuesday, January 08, 2002
True or false? The world in which we live
True or false? The world in which we live
January 8, 2002
By Peter Stair
Over break I tried my first fat free potato chips. They were tasty. They were cooked with a chemically engineered lipid, called olestra, which our taste buds recognize but our enzymes cannot properly digest. They are emblematic of our time: The Age of Illusions.
On my way home I took my first pilgrimage to Las Vegas, the mecca of the Age of Illusion.
It is a place of smoke and mirrors, flashing lights and seductive smiles. It is a place of windowless casinos, where the realities of night and day are lifted. Human companionship is offered as if it could be bought and hapless gamblers are made invisible. It is a place where Believers are encouraged to believe the illusion that there are short-cuts to personal and financial success. It is a desert which nonetheless gives the appearance of plentitude, where fountains gush, wastes are whisked away to some seemingly infinite dump and, if you gamble, drinks are ostensibly “cheap.”
Mirages.
Extravagant as Las Vegas can be, it is a brilliant satire of our culture.
At Stanford and elsewhere, we increasingly live in a world of 90 degree angles, concrete ground, cultivated gardens and fake flowers. Fruits have brand names, as if they were manufactured. Toilets and garbage trucks flush away our excrement, as if it simply disappeared. And, as we build our cities into the clouds, entertainment is our most common source of information. Living in illusion, we’re buffered, detached, ignorant of the vital feedback we need from our environmental support systems.
Socially, also, we’ve become more sheltered from each other. Computers and mobility separate us from the people we live with, just as cement and sewers separate us from the ground we live on. Instead of interacting with the people around us, we can use our cell phones to interact with people more distant. Instead of talking personally to someone, we can e-mail them. And when we feel sexy, we can have “virtual sex.” Less grounded and intimate in many relationships, we increase the likelihood that we’re living in delusion.
We’re inundated with opportunities to live in unreal, virtual worlds. We spend an increasing amount of our time playing on our computers and watching our televisions, meaning we spend more of our days interacting with neither the non-human world, nor humans themselves. In this world, we often actually prefer information that is specifically unrepresentative of reality. Our journalists tell us more often about unusual events than about broad trends. Our entertainers give us special effects and melodramas. Magazine covers are mostly digitally altered, airbrushed photos. We can pretend we’re video game characters who perform physically impossible feats.
Now, when we do interact with other humans, we increasingly talk about this virtual world we’ve created. We talk about our gizmos and games. We gossip about people we don’t even know, and who probably don’t really exist: personas with permanent stage names, like P. diddy and Kramer. Even when deciding whom to be our leaders, we talk about candidates with “image problems,” people without the “media savvy” to “perform” the role properly. A memorable slogan of our times is “image is everything.”
So what happens to us, as we construct the illusions of our age? As our world slowly becomes un-moored from reality, we risk a painful crash down to reality. Speculative bubbles burst. Enron goes out of business. The Titantic crashes. Liars get trapped. Terrorists follow through on threats we’d ignored. Illusions are dangerous.
But, more than that, it’s just not as much fun to live in fantasy. Picture someone at a dance party who’s flailing around, moving far too quickly and out of sync. That’s you and I. We can become so deaf to the music of the natural world that we lose our ability to dance to it, and, since we don’t hear the same beat, we have a harder time dancing with each other.
Sheltered in our cities, we can more easily believe we’re prospering, because it is easier to dismiss problems like global climate instability, nuclear waste, species extinction, soil erosion, collapsing fisheries and falling water tables.
“What environmental problem?” We can say, “I’ll believe it when I see it.”
Sheltered by our computers and our televisions, we more often take our social cues from non-reality. My father, an emergency room doctor, tells me that more people, confronted with unusual circumstances, are emulating the actors they see on TV. More fly into rages, threaten lawsuits, or command dramatically, “do everything, doctor!” They are making their world a TV world.
When we take too many cues from non-reality, we have difficulty interacting with reality. Alejandro Martinez, director of Stanford’s Counseling and Psychological Services, told me last year that she’d seen an “unprecedented number” of room-mates and dorm-mates having trouble getting along. She theorized that students who grew up with computers might incorrectly expect other humans to be just as pliable. Are we more often becoming social misfits?
Yet, despite the dangers of illusion, many of us at Stanford are working to further virtualize our world. Every time we work primarily for a credential or grade, we de-emphasize our value for actual growth and cast a vote for the world of appearances. How often do we plan or describe our life as if it were a resume?
We are programmers who will design the most exciting new video games. We are journalists or marketers who will work in an enormous and growing public relations industry, an industry that serves primarily to distort our information. We are teachers who will teach illusions. We are engineers or product designers who will further shelter people from the “discomforts” of reality. We are artists who will devote our talents not to elucidating deep truths but to the art form of the Age of Illusions: advertising, an art-form that seduces us into believing that buying something is always the solution.
We are illusionists.
But why feel bad about who we are when we can also work to spread clarity. Aware that cities are not the world, and that movie characters are not actual people, we can receive information more skeptically. We can practice trusting our own experiences more often, and words less often. We can become more experimental. Then we can become more creative in how we go about our daily lives. Psychologists call this awakening process “self-actualization.”
There is a difference between authentically connecting with our natural world and being safe from natural perils. There is a difference between being honest with other people and being rude. But I’m not so concerned about demarcating the boundary.
Because I think we know true connection and honesty when we feel it. And they feel so good ! I know the dissatisfaction of an entirely false smile, or a day spent in an office building, or a day writing e-mails. But I also know the feeling of looking into someone’s eyes and truly connecting with them. I know the feeling of communing with a tree, understanding its slower pace of living. We know how authentic, fresh and right these experiences are.
The real world is a beautiful place to live.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology, honestly. He’s not sure what he thinks about currencies and the gold standard. To be frank, he struggled to find an authentic tone in writing this column. For those interested in shedding illusions, he recommends a visit to a nearby organization called Magic, Inc. He is sincere in wanting to hear your feedback at pstair@stanford.edu.
January 8, 2002
By Peter Stair
Over break I tried my first fat free potato chips. They were tasty. They were cooked with a chemically engineered lipid, called olestra, which our taste buds recognize but our enzymes cannot properly digest. They are emblematic of our time: The Age of Illusions.
On my way home I took my first pilgrimage to Las Vegas, the mecca of the Age of Illusion.
It is a place of smoke and mirrors, flashing lights and seductive smiles. It is a place of windowless casinos, where the realities of night and day are lifted. Human companionship is offered as if it could be bought and hapless gamblers are made invisible. It is a place where Believers are encouraged to believe the illusion that there are short-cuts to personal and financial success. It is a desert which nonetheless gives the appearance of plentitude, where fountains gush, wastes are whisked away to some seemingly infinite dump and, if you gamble, drinks are ostensibly “cheap.”
Mirages.
Extravagant as Las Vegas can be, it is a brilliant satire of our culture.
At Stanford and elsewhere, we increasingly live in a world of 90 degree angles, concrete ground, cultivated gardens and fake flowers. Fruits have brand names, as if they were manufactured. Toilets and garbage trucks flush away our excrement, as if it simply disappeared. And, as we build our cities into the clouds, entertainment is our most common source of information. Living in illusion, we’re buffered, detached, ignorant of the vital feedback we need from our environmental support systems.
Socially, also, we’ve become more sheltered from each other. Computers and mobility separate us from the people we live with, just as cement and sewers separate us from the ground we live on. Instead of interacting with the people around us, we can use our cell phones to interact with people more distant. Instead of talking personally to someone, we can e-mail them. And when we feel sexy, we can have “virtual sex.” Less grounded and intimate in many relationships, we increase the likelihood that we’re living in delusion.
We’re inundated with opportunities to live in unreal, virtual worlds. We spend an increasing amount of our time playing on our computers and watching our televisions, meaning we spend more of our days interacting with neither the non-human world, nor humans themselves. In this world, we often actually prefer information that is specifically unrepresentative of reality. Our journalists tell us more often about unusual events than about broad trends. Our entertainers give us special effects and melodramas. Magazine covers are mostly digitally altered, airbrushed photos. We can pretend we’re video game characters who perform physically impossible feats.
Now, when we do interact with other humans, we increasingly talk about this virtual world we’ve created. We talk about our gizmos and games. We gossip about people we don’t even know, and who probably don’t really exist: personas with permanent stage names, like P. diddy and Kramer. Even when deciding whom to be our leaders, we talk about candidates with “image problems,” people without the “media savvy” to “perform” the role properly. A memorable slogan of our times is “image is everything.”
So what happens to us, as we construct the illusions of our age? As our world slowly becomes un-moored from reality, we risk a painful crash down to reality. Speculative bubbles burst. Enron goes out of business. The Titantic crashes. Liars get trapped. Terrorists follow through on threats we’d ignored. Illusions are dangerous.
But, more than that, it’s just not as much fun to live in fantasy. Picture someone at a dance party who’s flailing around, moving far too quickly and out of sync. That’s you and I. We can become so deaf to the music of the natural world that we lose our ability to dance to it, and, since we don’t hear the same beat, we have a harder time dancing with each other.
Sheltered in our cities, we can more easily believe we’re prospering, because it is easier to dismiss problems like global climate instability, nuclear waste, species extinction, soil erosion, collapsing fisheries and falling water tables.
“What environmental problem?” We can say, “I’ll believe it when I see it.”
Sheltered by our computers and our televisions, we more often take our social cues from non-reality. My father, an emergency room doctor, tells me that more people, confronted with unusual circumstances, are emulating the actors they see on TV. More fly into rages, threaten lawsuits, or command dramatically, “do everything, doctor!” They are making their world a TV world.
When we take too many cues from non-reality, we have difficulty interacting with reality. Alejandro Martinez, director of Stanford’s Counseling and Psychological Services, told me last year that she’d seen an “unprecedented number” of room-mates and dorm-mates having trouble getting along. She theorized that students who grew up with computers might incorrectly expect other humans to be just as pliable. Are we more often becoming social misfits?
Yet, despite the dangers of illusion, many of us at Stanford are working to further virtualize our world. Every time we work primarily for a credential or grade, we de-emphasize our value for actual growth and cast a vote for the world of appearances. How often do we plan or describe our life as if it were a resume?
We are programmers who will design the most exciting new video games. We are journalists or marketers who will work in an enormous and growing public relations industry, an industry that serves primarily to distort our information. We are teachers who will teach illusions. We are engineers or product designers who will further shelter people from the “discomforts” of reality. We are artists who will devote our talents not to elucidating deep truths but to the art form of the Age of Illusions: advertising, an art-form that seduces us into believing that buying something is always the solution.
We are illusionists.
But why feel bad about who we are when we can also work to spread clarity. Aware that cities are not the world, and that movie characters are not actual people, we can receive information more skeptically. We can practice trusting our own experiences more often, and words less often. We can become more experimental. Then we can become more creative in how we go about our daily lives. Psychologists call this awakening process “self-actualization.”
There is a difference between authentically connecting with our natural world and being safe from natural perils. There is a difference between being honest with other people and being rude. But I’m not so concerned about demarcating the boundary.
Because I think we know true connection and honesty when we feel it. And they feel so good ! I know the dissatisfaction of an entirely false smile, or a day spent in an office building, or a day writing e-mails. But I also know the feeling of looking into someone’s eyes and truly connecting with them. I know the feeling of communing with a tree, understanding its slower pace of living. We know how authentic, fresh and right these experiences are.
The real world is a beautiful place to live.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology, honestly. He’s not sure what he thinks about currencies and the gold standard. To be frank, he struggled to find an authentic tone in writing this column. For those interested in shedding illusions, he recommends a visit to a nearby organization called Magic, Inc. He is sincere in wanting to hear your feedback at pstair@stanford.edu.
Tuesday, November 27, 2001
The emperor's clothes
The emperor's clothes
November 27, 2001
By Peter Stair
Inexperienced in the ways of the world, can the young also be clear-eyed prophets? I think yes. And I think we young folks can help others by speaking out more often, more loudly and now.
Others agree that the fresh-minded are often wise. Many professors acknowledge that most of their best ideas come from students still unschooled by conventional thinking. Thomas Kuhn, in his history of science, took this even further, saying that every major shift in human knowledge has come when someone was willing to question the “paradigm” they lived in, whether that paradigm was the Ptolemaic universe or the divine right of kings. Buddhists say that we approach enlightenment by first approaching the world with a simpler mind, the mind of the Buddha. And, in the business world, firms hire consultants, and CEOs like Bill Gates and Andy Grove take sabbaticals in order to see things from a fresh perspective.
As youths it is especially easy for us to have this fresh perspective. Because we haven’t identified ourselves as a cog in the status quo, we are more free to criticize it without feeling we are criticizing our life’s work. We are less invested, less afraid and less indoctrinated. Remember, it was a child who said the king had no clothes.
It is no surprise that modern college students are often the leaders of social change. We have changed the world by starting up high-tech companies and by calling for civil rights for women and minorities.
What is surprising, though, is how easy we seem to think these changes can be. Especially in calls for social justice, we are easily discouraged by the eloquent and confident arguments of our commissars. To be sure, seeking knowledge from those with more experience is a smart strategy. But how often do we trample our intuition with uncertainty? How often do we defer to experts, intelligent people who are nonetheless worthy of suspicion by their very pre-eminence? At what point do we stop thinking for ourselves?
Nazism, slavery and feudalism were once eloquently explained by men of great prominent and respectability. Almost undoubtedly these men told young folks that they didn’t understand how the world worked, or that certain things were just human nature.
Which of our current customs will our grandchildren consider abhorrent?
I’m not sure, but I’m virtually certain that there are some. And I, a 21-year-old, am going to risk being wrong by saying what I feel.
We are deteriorating both the physical environment upon which we depend for survival and the human connections upon which we depend for meaning. Both are the result of our societal
infrastructure.
I think many of us realize this already. I think it is a big fat elephant in the room that few are talking about.
We may not say it, or even profess to believe it, because our understanding often lies below the level of our frontal lobes. But our bodies know: we are perpetually stressed, under-slept, over-fed and loaded with various drugs and synthetic poisons. We are aware of this strain somewhere in our consciousness.
Sometimes this awareness may manifest as a question. “Why am I always so busy that I don’t feel in control?” “Why am I 20 years old and saying that I don’t have time to date?” “Is this college, really ‘the best time of my life?’ ” And, for some, “Why do I feel guilty about my options for employment?”
We may question why we define prosperity as a time of increasing Gross Domestic Product, which says that clear-cutting a forest or hiring someone else to take care of our children is an unmitigated good.
Don’t people value more than priced “goods and services?”
Indices of social health that account for a broader ranger of variables, like crime, working and commuting hours, and environmental quality, indicate that our lives have been growing steadily more difficult since around 1970. I think we sense this.
In our times of “prosperity,” affording a nice place to live is becoming more and more difficult, so is finding a quiet place for reflection, or even a place not made of concrete. Traffic is epidemic. Our education system is failing. And our bridges and roads are falling apart.
As companies grow, workers and employers feel less loyalty towards one another. As we build more gated communities and jails, and hire more police officers, we indicate our fear of each other. Increasingly, we are going to bowling alleys alone.
Storing our elders in nursing homes doesn’t quite feel right, nor does always considering death a problem, rather than an essential part of life.
Biologists tell us that we are experiencing the greatest extinction event in tens of millions of years, that it’s possible, probable, that 90 percent of extant species will go extinct in a hundred years. Quietly, more and more authorities are saying the same thing: that we must act immediately and intensively to reduce more serious environmental degradation.
Global climate instability is already real, as the number of natural disasters serious enough to require outside help has increased from 20 in the 1950s to 86 in the 1990s. Meanwhile poor people deforest housands of acres of forest land in search of fuel, while Americans drive SUVs.
Americans are growing more and more obese. The number of us afflicted by Diabetes II has skyrocketed in only the last 15 years and grade school children grow more and more pudgy each year. Meanwhile McDonalds still spend billions of dollars pushing its products, and millions of non-Americans starve each year.
If the poor don’t starve, they contract diseases that might easily spread back. Or they grow angry with the disparities they see and so increase the building international rage against wealthy Americans.
These are serious problems, requiring serious introspection and something more than simple reforms. Yet only six companies — companies so large they are intimately invested in the current arrangement — control most of our news, music, books and movies. Together with their advertisers, these companies give us information that rarely mentions the disturbing trends that define our era.
We, for our part, are willing to believe everything is okay. We buy the distractions, turn off the (rare) upsetting programs and proceed as if our age were nothing but gilded. Some of us note problems, but have no satisfying solutions. Others are fanatical: depending on a blanket solution — like “more free markets” or “education” — for everything.
Who among us will protest what we feel today? There are many opportunities, in the dining hall, in class, with room-mates, to parents, on e-mail and via a handful of student groups.
Who among us, in making preparations for a career, are preparing to think outside of the narrow box of convention?
Who will be the accountants who insist that ignoring the environment is doctoring the books? Who will be the mathematicians who will say that a society cannot be dependent on perpetual economic growth (perpetually compounding interest) because there are no natural analogies ?
Who will be the psychologists who speak out against the endless blitz of sophisticated propaganda that is our information system, the advertising that comprises the largest social psychology experiment ever conducted?
Who will be the doctors who say that we’re becoming fatter not only because we’re eating more, but because we’re lonely, stressed or dissatisfied? Who will be the spiritual leaders who encourage us to find a more comfortable relationship with our natural environment?
Who will be the politicians willing to lose an election in order to make a public statement of principle? And who is willing to be a true leader by modeling their beliefs with more than words but with a integrated lifestyle?
Most importantly, whatever they stand for, who will be willing to say unpopular things?
I think many of these leaders might come from Stanford.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. For the record, he does not think the sky is falling. He is interested in what you have to say, so e-mail him at pstair@stanford.edu.
November 27, 2001
By Peter Stair
Inexperienced in the ways of the world, can the young also be clear-eyed prophets? I think yes. And I think we young folks can help others by speaking out more often, more loudly and now.
Others agree that the fresh-minded are often wise. Many professors acknowledge that most of their best ideas come from students still unschooled by conventional thinking. Thomas Kuhn, in his history of science, took this even further, saying that every major shift in human knowledge has come when someone was willing to question the “paradigm” they lived in, whether that paradigm was the Ptolemaic universe or the divine right of kings. Buddhists say that we approach enlightenment by first approaching the world with a simpler mind, the mind of the Buddha. And, in the business world, firms hire consultants, and CEOs like Bill Gates and Andy Grove take sabbaticals in order to see things from a fresh perspective.
As youths it is especially easy for us to have this fresh perspective. Because we haven’t identified ourselves as a cog in the status quo, we are more free to criticize it without feeling we are criticizing our life’s work. We are less invested, less afraid and less indoctrinated. Remember, it was a child who said the king had no clothes.
It is no surprise that modern college students are often the leaders of social change. We have changed the world by starting up high-tech companies and by calling for civil rights for women and minorities.
What is surprising, though, is how easy we seem to think these changes can be. Especially in calls for social justice, we are easily discouraged by the eloquent and confident arguments of our commissars. To be sure, seeking knowledge from those with more experience is a smart strategy. But how often do we trample our intuition with uncertainty? How often do we defer to experts, intelligent people who are nonetheless worthy of suspicion by their very pre-eminence? At what point do we stop thinking for ourselves?
Nazism, slavery and feudalism were once eloquently explained by men of great prominent and respectability. Almost undoubtedly these men told young folks that they didn’t understand how the world worked, or that certain things were just human nature.
Which of our current customs will our grandchildren consider abhorrent?
I’m not sure, but I’m virtually certain that there are some. And I, a 21-year-old, am going to risk being wrong by saying what I feel.
We are deteriorating both the physical environment upon which we depend for survival and the human connections upon which we depend for meaning. Both are the result of our societal
infrastructure.
I think many of us realize this already. I think it is a big fat elephant in the room that few are talking about.
We may not say it, or even profess to believe it, because our understanding often lies below the level of our frontal lobes. But our bodies know: we are perpetually stressed, under-slept, over-fed and loaded with various drugs and synthetic poisons. We are aware of this strain somewhere in our consciousness.
Sometimes this awareness may manifest as a question. “Why am I always so busy that I don’t feel in control?” “Why am I 20 years old and saying that I don’t have time to date?” “Is this college, really ‘the best time of my life?’ ” And, for some, “Why do I feel guilty about my options for employment?”
We may question why we define prosperity as a time of increasing Gross Domestic Product, which says that clear-cutting a forest or hiring someone else to take care of our children is an unmitigated good.
Don’t people value more than priced “goods and services?”
Indices of social health that account for a broader ranger of variables, like crime, working and commuting hours, and environmental quality, indicate that our lives have been growing steadily more difficult since around 1970. I think we sense this.
In our times of “prosperity,” affording a nice place to live is becoming more and more difficult, so is finding a quiet place for reflection, or even a place not made of concrete. Traffic is epidemic. Our education system is failing. And our bridges and roads are falling apart.
As companies grow, workers and employers feel less loyalty towards one another. As we build more gated communities and jails, and hire more police officers, we indicate our fear of each other. Increasingly, we are going to bowling alleys alone.
Storing our elders in nursing homes doesn’t quite feel right, nor does always considering death a problem, rather than an essential part of life.
Biologists tell us that we are experiencing the greatest extinction event in tens of millions of years, that it’s possible, probable, that 90 percent of extant species will go extinct in a hundred years. Quietly, more and more authorities are saying the same thing: that we must act immediately and intensively to reduce more serious environmental degradation.
Global climate instability is already real, as the number of natural disasters serious enough to require outside help has increased from 20 in the 1950s to 86 in the 1990s. Meanwhile poor people deforest housands of acres of forest land in search of fuel, while Americans drive SUVs.
Americans are growing more and more obese. The number of us afflicted by Diabetes II has skyrocketed in only the last 15 years and grade school children grow more and more pudgy each year. Meanwhile McDonalds still spend billions of dollars pushing its products, and millions of non-Americans starve each year.
If the poor don’t starve, they contract diseases that might easily spread back. Or they grow angry with the disparities they see and so increase the building international rage against wealthy Americans.
These are serious problems, requiring serious introspection and something more than simple reforms. Yet only six companies — companies so large they are intimately invested in the current arrangement — control most of our news, music, books and movies. Together with their advertisers, these companies give us information that rarely mentions the disturbing trends that define our era.
We, for our part, are willing to believe everything is okay. We buy the distractions, turn off the (rare) upsetting programs and proceed as if our age were nothing but gilded. Some of us note problems, but have no satisfying solutions. Others are fanatical: depending on a blanket solution — like “more free markets” or “education” — for everything.
Who among us will protest what we feel today? There are many opportunities, in the dining hall, in class, with room-mates, to parents, on e-mail and via a handful of student groups.
Who among us, in making preparations for a career, are preparing to think outside of the narrow box of convention?
Who will be the accountants who insist that ignoring the environment is doctoring the books? Who will be the mathematicians who will say that a society cannot be dependent on perpetual economic growth (perpetually compounding interest) because there are no natural analogies ?
Who will be the psychologists who speak out against the endless blitz of sophisticated propaganda that is our information system, the advertising that comprises the largest social psychology experiment ever conducted?
Who will be the doctors who say that we’re becoming fatter not only because we’re eating more, but because we’re lonely, stressed or dissatisfied? Who will be the spiritual leaders who encourage us to find a more comfortable relationship with our natural environment?
Who will be the politicians willing to lose an election in order to make a public statement of principle? And who is willing to be a true leader by modeling their beliefs with more than words but with a integrated lifestyle?
Most importantly, whatever they stand for, who will be willing to say unpopular things?
I think many of these leaders might come from Stanford.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. For the record, he does not think the sky is falling. He is interested in what you have to say, so e-mail him at pstair@stanford.edu.
Tuesday, November 20, 2001
The sparks of revolution
The sparks of revolution
November 20, 2001
By Peter Stair
There is a truth lurking within our minds. We know it, but we don’t yet realize it. We’re afraid to believe it, but when we do, we are more joyful. If most humans realized it, there would be a revolution. We regularly tell each other its opposite.
It is this: we can have enormous influence on each other.
Consider standing ovations. They start when one, two, maybe five people stand after an applause begins. As others decide whether they agree with this assessment of the performance, a few more stand. Then a few more. All of a sudden, everyone’s on their feet.
Since there’s usually a pause before the whole crowd stands, we know the ovation could have just fizzled. This makes it particularly exciting if we stood at just the right moment — the critical point — so it feels as if we pulled the hesitant members of the audience from their seats. We probably did.
Because we fail to see, truly, that the world works like standing ovations — with critical points and sudden changes — we miss the critical opportunities we have to influence the world around us.
It’s not that we don’t have lots of evidence from the natural world. It is replete with examples of negative feedback loops (equilibrium) apparently tipping into positive feedback loops (self-perpetuating change). A neuron doesn’t fire until it receives just enough stimuli to push it over the edge. The chain reaction of an atomic explosion requires a critical mass of uranium. The ketchup sticks in the bottle until a single tap pushes it all out. The world’s population suddenly shot up from one to six billion. Colloquially, we even say that one straw of hay breaks the camel’s back.
The problem is that we prefer to view ourselves as powerless non-participants in a story of life. We attribute real power to characters like “inflation,” “Israel” and “General Electric,” forgetting that these are abstract names for the actions of millions of people. And we like to pit these characters against each other: The “Federal Reserve” fights “inflation” and tries to influence “the invisible hand.” “China” faces off against “Taiwan.” When we tell the story this way, it’s simple and exciting.
The few human beings that we consider characters in our story, we make into heroes — unrealistically glorified individuals. We like to say that Abraham Lincoln “freed” the slaves, that Charles Darwin “discovered” evolution and that Rosa Parks was “responsible” for the Montgomery Bus Boycott. How ridiculous! In saying such things we give these people credit for the actions of thousands of other people.
Take Darwin and evolution. His father and others had discussed the same idea around the dinner table, in the context of seminal thinkers like Malthus, Hutton and Lamarck. Indeed, the concept was ripe, as Alfred Wallace proved by independently writing of it a few years after Darwin. Did Darwin “discover” evolution or did he brush off the final traces of dust, the lucky man to have collected a critical mass of others’ ideas?
Or better yet, consider one of our favorite heroes, Rosa Parks, the black woman who famously refused to sit in the back of the bus. We so often play up the spontaneity and romance of her refusal that we ignore the real context. This was neither her first act of protest nor the first time a black person refused to sit in the back of a bus in Montgomery. Did she cause the Montgomery Bus Boycott, or was that the work of thousands of people? Isn’t it more accurate to say that she was the woman who refused to cooperate with an unpopular policy at the right time — the critical point?
Of course, these critical moments are noteworthy: they signal an important shift. But which is more important, that there was a standing ovation, or that John Doe participated?
When we talk about someone single-handedly causing the standing ovation, we concede our power to them. To say that “Rosa Parks caused the Montgomery Bus Boycott” is to suggest that others, including ourselves, didn’t have a role, that we were merely spectators. In the same way, we speak of “markets” as if they existed independent of people like us, or “the government” as if it weren’t a creation of citizens like us. So we feel small, to our own detriment. We complain about politics, but we don’t vote. We complain about single-minded pursuit of profit, but eagerly work for and own companies doing just that.
Advertisers — people whose livelihood depends on creating mini social trends — are not fools. They understand how powerful we can be as billboards. So, at every opportunity, they plaster messages on our chests, backs, butts, ankles, arms, foreheads, shoulders and legs. People who like our clothing, for example, buy their own and then advertise to the next customer.
But this advertising strategy only works when we don’t see what we signify to others. We’re not wearing five-inch letters spelling “Tommy Hilfiger” because we want to recommend the product to our friends; we’re wearing it because we feel powerless and want to associate ourselves with something we do consider powerful. We’re even willing to pay a premium for the association.
Why are we so willing to deny responsibility for our actions? Perhaps because advertisers try to convince us otherwise. Perhaps because we’d be ashamed to look at what we’re endorsing. Perhaps we’re scared, lazy or complacent. Ultimately we deny responsibility because we don’t want it.
But we are influential, and that means we’re responsible. Let’s recognize that we’re turning our planet into a sauna, depleting our water tables, fraying our social fabric and seeing thousands of symbolic “canary species” die in the mineshaft that we’ve made of our habitat. And the reason we live in a world like this is that we’ve diffused responsibility onto others, or onto “inflation,” “China” and “General Electric.”
Let’s also recognize that we each have the power to turn this situation around. Standing ovations don’t happen unless enough people stand at the right time, and now is the right time. We can take the Caltrain instead of driving. We can be friendly to strangers, eat less meat and sell our stock in Nike. And we can know that we’re having more than a microscopic impact, because others are watching.
We don’t even have to wait until we can agree on a policy or articulate a step-by-step vision. This will come — after we change ourselves. “Political infeasibility” is too often a euphemism for procrastination.
To paraphrase Mohandas Gandhi, we can BE the change we want to see in the world, starting today.
And once we take a stand, there’s a chance others will join us in ovation.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. He hopes the difference he makes is positive. He likes your e-mails at pstair@stanford.edu.
November 20, 2001
By Peter Stair
There is a truth lurking within our minds. We know it, but we don’t yet realize it. We’re afraid to believe it, but when we do, we are more joyful. If most humans realized it, there would be a revolution. We regularly tell each other its opposite.
It is this: we can have enormous influence on each other.
Consider standing ovations. They start when one, two, maybe five people stand after an applause begins. As others decide whether they agree with this assessment of the performance, a few more stand. Then a few more. All of a sudden, everyone’s on their feet.
Since there’s usually a pause before the whole crowd stands, we know the ovation could have just fizzled. This makes it particularly exciting if we stood at just the right moment — the critical point — so it feels as if we pulled the hesitant members of the audience from their seats. We probably did.
Because we fail to see, truly, that the world works like standing ovations — with critical points and sudden changes — we miss the critical opportunities we have to influence the world around us.
It’s not that we don’t have lots of evidence from the natural world. It is replete with examples of negative feedback loops (equilibrium) apparently tipping into positive feedback loops (self-perpetuating change). A neuron doesn’t fire until it receives just enough stimuli to push it over the edge. The chain reaction of an atomic explosion requires a critical mass of uranium. The ketchup sticks in the bottle until a single tap pushes it all out. The world’s population suddenly shot up from one to six billion. Colloquially, we even say that one straw of hay breaks the camel’s back.
The problem is that we prefer to view ourselves as powerless non-participants in a story of life. We attribute real power to characters like “inflation,” “Israel” and “General Electric,” forgetting that these are abstract names for the actions of millions of people. And we like to pit these characters against each other: The “Federal Reserve” fights “inflation” and tries to influence “the invisible hand.” “China” faces off against “Taiwan.” When we tell the story this way, it’s simple and exciting.
The few human beings that we consider characters in our story, we make into heroes — unrealistically glorified individuals. We like to say that Abraham Lincoln “freed” the slaves, that Charles Darwin “discovered” evolution and that Rosa Parks was “responsible” for the Montgomery Bus Boycott. How ridiculous! In saying such things we give these people credit for the actions of thousands of other people.
Take Darwin and evolution. His father and others had discussed the same idea around the dinner table, in the context of seminal thinkers like Malthus, Hutton and Lamarck. Indeed, the concept was ripe, as Alfred Wallace proved by independently writing of it a few years after Darwin. Did Darwin “discover” evolution or did he brush off the final traces of dust, the lucky man to have collected a critical mass of others’ ideas?
Or better yet, consider one of our favorite heroes, Rosa Parks, the black woman who famously refused to sit in the back of the bus. We so often play up the spontaneity and romance of her refusal that we ignore the real context. This was neither her first act of protest nor the first time a black person refused to sit in the back of a bus in Montgomery. Did she cause the Montgomery Bus Boycott, or was that the work of thousands of people? Isn’t it more accurate to say that she was the woman who refused to cooperate with an unpopular policy at the right time — the critical point?
Of course, these critical moments are noteworthy: they signal an important shift. But which is more important, that there was a standing ovation, or that John Doe participated?
When we talk about someone single-handedly causing the standing ovation, we concede our power to them. To say that “Rosa Parks caused the Montgomery Bus Boycott” is to suggest that others, including ourselves, didn’t have a role, that we were merely spectators. In the same way, we speak of “markets” as if they existed independent of people like us, or “the government” as if it weren’t a creation of citizens like us. So we feel small, to our own detriment. We complain about politics, but we don’t vote. We complain about single-minded pursuit of profit, but eagerly work for and own companies doing just that.
Advertisers — people whose livelihood depends on creating mini social trends — are not fools. They understand how powerful we can be as billboards. So, at every opportunity, they plaster messages on our chests, backs, butts, ankles, arms, foreheads, shoulders and legs. People who like our clothing, for example, buy their own and then advertise to the next customer.
But this advertising strategy only works when we don’t see what we signify to others. We’re not wearing five-inch letters spelling “Tommy Hilfiger” because we want to recommend the product to our friends; we’re wearing it because we feel powerless and want to associate ourselves with something we do consider powerful. We’re even willing to pay a premium for the association.
Why are we so willing to deny responsibility for our actions? Perhaps because advertisers try to convince us otherwise. Perhaps because we’d be ashamed to look at what we’re endorsing. Perhaps we’re scared, lazy or complacent. Ultimately we deny responsibility because we don’t want it.
But we are influential, and that means we’re responsible. Let’s recognize that we’re turning our planet into a sauna, depleting our water tables, fraying our social fabric and seeing thousands of symbolic “canary species” die in the mineshaft that we’ve made of our habitat. And the reason we live in a world like this is that we’ve diffused responsibility onto others, or onto “inflation,” “China” and “General Electric.”
Let’s also recognize that we each have the power to turn this situation around. Standing ovations don’t happen unless enough people stand at the right time, and now is the right time. We can take the Caltrain instead of driving. We can be friendly to strangers, eat less meat and sell our stock in Nike. And we can know that we’re having more than a microscopic impact, because others are watching.
We don’t even have to wait until we can agree on a policy or articulate a step-by-step vision. This will come — after we change ourselves. “Political infeasibility” is too often a euphemism for procrastination.
To paraphrase Mohandas Gandhi, we can BE the change we want to see in the world, starting today.
And once we take a stand, there’s a chance others will join us in ovation.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. He hopes the difference he makes is positive. He likes your e-mails at pstair@stanford.edu.
Tuesday, November 13, 2001
Big Game, Big Column
Big Game, Big Column
November 13, 2001
By Peter Stair
I wrote about sports last week. I’m going to write about sports again this week. If you think I’m repeating topics, you are correct. This is because sports, like the Civil War, is a subject which remains perpetually worthy of additional study, despite the intellectual energies of thousands — nay, millions — of scholars.
Sports are a way of upholding traditions and ways of life, bringing people together, and teaching us valuable lessons. This is exactly why I’m so concerned that Stanford students don’t take their rivalry with Cal very seriously.
Why, just this last week I heard fellow Stanford students utter comments like, “oh boy, we’re playing Cal [whom everyone knows is 0-9 so far] this week;” “Why are we made to feel like party poopers if we don’t want to pay $50 to watch a bunch of guys bump into each other for three hours?” and even, “I don’t care who wins. I’m not going.”
Do these students not understand that the Stanford-Cal rivalry has lasted for over 104 years?
I mean, Big Game is a Big Deal. Going is a critical part of the Stanford Experience. (It is our right and privilege: a privilege of the people who are right for Stanford, and a right for the privileged who go here.) Think of all the alumni who tirelessly attended football games in order to preserve our right to pay a fee to attend Big Game.
Even if the game itself is unexciting, we can take pleasure in the long tradition of sports that we are participating in. We can chuckle fondly as we remember the first hunting games of our ancestors, and we can smile distantly as we contemplate the great Olympic Games of the Greeks.
Modern sports as we know them probably began during the Roman Empire, where the Emperor would graciously sponsor exotic and elaborate games, called “Bread and Circus,” to appease the discontent masses. Distracted from their oppressed lives, the masses returned adoration to their Emperor. To do otherwise would be rude.
Today, we honor this tradition by attending Big Game. When we don’t attend, however, we are rude. And I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to spit in the face of the Emperor of America!
More than a tradition or gift, though, sports are about the American Way of Life. Just list our virtues, and the connection will be obvious. We are violent; sports are violent. We are loud; sports are loud. We are sedentary; so are spectators at sports games. We like to eat; there is food at sports games. We are fanatics; sports “fan” is short for sports fanatic. We like colorful things; sports uniforms are colorful. We like variety; there are now almost 1,000 sports leagues in America.
Sports are what Americans think about. Some days, I don’t even read the “Business,” “International” and “Local” sections of the newspaper. I go directly to “Sports!” As the Sports section gets thicker and thicker, my work is getting harder, but I always know what the chattering classes are saying about Stanford.
Sports are what Americans talk about. They are the common ground we share. We cannot talk with Europeans about them (they have their own kinds of sports). And we cannot talk about third-rail issues like politics and religion.
Finally, sports are what bring us together. Can you think of any other cause that brings together 100,000 people in one place? Can you think of any other cause that does so on a more-than-weekly basis? No, not the orphaned kids, or the starving foreigners, not even cancer or love. No, like it or not, sports are the only cause that brings us together. And, of all our sports, football brings us together the most.
More than just numbers of people, think of all the resources that a football game brings together. If there are 100,000 people, and each person spends, say, $50 on a ticket, $2 on transportation and $2 on food, that’s $5,400,000 that could have gone somewhere else.
Think of it from another perspective, if we pooled the time and mental energy of the millions of people who either attend or watch a single football game on TV, we have the equivalent manpower of several medium-sized corporations for a year. What but football could focus so many valuable resources on one thing?
The only comparable concentration of people and resources that I can think of is a huge army, and I think that is an apt comparison. Armies fight to protect a people’s way of life. Sports crowds gather to honor the American way of life.
Moreover sports, like wars, are a manifestation of what Freud called thanatos, the drive to destroy. We like to break stuff (remember that game with the pencils, where you and your opponent took turns snapping your pencils against each other until one of them broke?). We like to watch other people break stuff (like sports records and bones).
We come together to break stuff, and we come together to watch other people break stuff.
It’s not only part of what makes us American; it’s part of what makes us human.
We must preserve our humanity. We must preserve our way of life. And the price of these things, so goes the saying, is eternal vigilance. Just as an army must not have deserters, sports crowds must not diminish.
Stanford students have a duty not to be apathetic during Big Game week.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. He thinks sports can be educational and that athletes can teach us things. This is why he wears only Nike apparel. When he’s serious, he says that coaches should be tenured faculty and that, if athletes have scholarships, every other department should offer scholarships too. He wants more people to e-mail him at pstair@stanford.edu. Remember the salty fields of Carthage.
November 13, 2001
By Peter Stair
I wrote about sports last week. I’m going to write about sports again this week. If you think I’m repeating topics, you are correct. This is because sports, like the Civil War, is a subject which remains perpetually worthy of additional study, despite the intellectual energies of thousands — nay, millions — of scholars.
Sports are a way of upholding traditions and ways of life, bringing people together, and teaching us valuable lessons. This is exactly why I’m so concerned that Stanford students don’t take their rivalry with Cal very seriously.
Why, just this last week I heard fellow Stanford students utter comments like, “oh boy, we’re playing Cal [whom everyone knows is 0-9 so far] this week;” “Why are we made to feel like party poopers if we don’t want to pay $50 to watch a bunch of guys bump into each other for three hours?” and even, “I don’t care who wins. I’m not going.”
Do these students not understand that the Stanford-Cal rivalry has lasted for over 104 years?
I mean, Big Game is a Big Deal. Going is a critical part of the Stanford Experience. (It is our right and privilege: a privilege of the people who are right for Stanford, and a right for the privileged who go here.) Think of all the alumni who tirelessly attended football games in order to preserve our right to pay a fee to attend Big Game.
Even if the game itself is unexciting, we can take pleasure in the long tradition of sports that we are participating in. We can chuckle fondly as we remember the first hunting games of our ancestors, and we can smile distantly as we contemplate the great Olympic Games of the Greeks.
Modern sports as we know them probably began during the Roman Empire, where the Emperor would graciously sponsor exotic and elaborate games, called “Bread and Circus,” to appease the discontent masses. Distracted from their oppressed lives, the masses returned adoration to their Emperor. To do otherwise would be rude.
Today, we honor this tradition by attending Big Game. When we don’t attend, however, we are rude. And I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to spit in the face of the Emperor of America!
More than a tradition or gift, though, sports are about the American Way of Life. Just list our virtues, and the connection will be obvious. We are violent; sports are violent. We are loud; sports are loud. We are sedentary; so are spectators at sports games. We like to eat; there is food at sports games. We are fanatics; sports “fan” is short for sports fanatic. We like colorful things; sports uniforms are colorful. We like variety; there are now almost 1,000 sports leagues in America.
Sports are what Americans think about. Some days, I don’t even read the “Business,” “International” and “Local” sections of the newspaper. I go directly to “Sports!” As the Sports section gets thicker and thicker, my work is getting harder, but I always know what the chattering classes are saying about Stanford.
Sports are what Americans talk about. They are the common ground we share. We cannot talk with Europeans about them (they have their own kinds of sports). And we cannot talk about third-rail issues like politics and religion.
Finally, sports are what bring us together. Can you think of any other cause that brings together 100,000 people in one place? Can you think of any other cause that does so on a more-than-weekly basis? No, not the orphaned kids, or the starving foreigners, not even cancer or love. No, like it or not, sports are the only cause that brings us together. And, of all our sports, football brings us together the most.
More than just numbers of people, think of all the resources that a football game brings together. If there are 100,000 people, and each person spends, say, $50 on a ticket, $2 on transportation and $2 on food, that’s $5,400,000 that could have gone somewhere else.
Think of it from another perspective, if we pooled the time and mental energy of the millions of people who either attend or watch a single football game on TV, we have the equivalent manpower of several medium-sized corporations for a year. What but football could focus so many valuable resources on one thing?
The only comparable concentration of people and resources that I can think of is a huge army, and I think that is an apt comparison. Armies fight to protect a people’s way of life. Sports crowds gather to honor the American way of life.
Moreover sports, like wars, are a manifestation of what Freud called thanatos, the drive to destroy. We like to break stuff (remember that game with the pencils, where you and your opponent took turns snapping your pencils against each other until one of them broke?). We like to watch other people break stuff (like sports records and bones).
We come together to break stuff, and we come together to watch other people break stuff.
It’s not only part of what makes us American; it’s part of what makes us human.
We must preserve our humanity. We must preserve our way of life. And the price of these things, so goes the saying, is eternal vigilance. Just as an army must not have deserters, sports crowds must not diminish.
Stanford students have a duty not to be apathetic during Big Game week.
Peter Stair is a junior studying human ecology. He thinks sports can be educational and that athletes can teach us things. This is why he wears only Nike apparel. When he’s serious, he says that coaches should be tenured faculty and that, if athletes have scholarships, every other department should offer scholarships too. He wants more people to e-mail him at pstair@stanford.edu. Remember the salty fields of Carthage.
Tuesday, November 06, 2001
Our eyes: wide shut
Our eyes: wide shut
November 6, 2001
By Peter Stair
Three seemingly unrelated events happened last week:
First, a study was released showing that the amount students are willing to pay (and that universities have the courage to charge) for a college certification continues to increase faster than inflation.
Second, another wealthy guy has made another outrageously large, record-setting, hundreds-of-millions-of-dollars donation to an already wealthy and expensive university. This time it was $600 million and the university was Cal Tech. Last time it was more than $400 million and the university was Stanford.
Third, last Tuesday, a number of homeless people and advocates stopped at Stanford on their march from San Jose to San Francisco. They told us how difficult it has been for them to get proper health care or education for their children and how impossible it has been for them to compete with Silicon Valley millionaires for housing. They asked for “compassion” from an uncharitable economic system.
This is a column not so much about these three events, but rather about the absurd world in which they would happen, and then be considered separately.
But, I must note that last week was also a truly phenomenal week in the world of sports. Especially in times like these, how can I avoid remarking on the Stanford football team?
Now I know many people have already written many fine sports columns, and these columnists are often both observant and lyrical. But it wouldn’t right for me to stay quiet.
Why? Because I learned something important over the weekend:
After an incident in the kitchen, I realized that I bleed. I bleed Red. A Red that looks suspiciously like Cardinal Red.
And, man oh man, was I bleeding after the Card’s exceedingly painful loss to Washington this week.
Truly, we were all suffering as we saw our Stanford team-mates writhing in agony and blood on the field last Saturday after the Huskies scorched us, 42-28.
It was a miserable sight.
It was the site of a Great Power falling, a bloody moment we will probably never forget. Before our eyes, we saw it happening, the Stanford Cardinal — a team that could have Won It All — falling from the ninth-and-two-thirds best team in the country to the 15th-and-one-third best team.
Our loss to Washington, to put it simply, was nothing less than totally devastating.
At times like these it’s important to have a little perspective. We can take walks and call relatives and remember that we will all die eventually. But, perhaps most importantly, we can remember the bottom line: Stanford football still has a bright future.
To put it in other words, if Stanford were a city-state, and our football team were our army, we could expect many years of bloody conquest and pillaging. And, when we are powerful again, we can remember this loss.
Just as Cato once said, “remember Carthage,” we can say, “remember the University of Washington.”
Speaking of remembering, though, will anyone forget how God dramatically turned against the Yankees this weekend?
How ironic! The Team of Destiny failed to win the Series That Everyone Will Talk About, Forever.
It all came down to the blood-filled ninth inning. Actually, it was not just the ninth inning, it was also the ninth inning of the seventh game. And not only did it come down to the ninth inning of the seventh game, but it also came down to the last two outs. The last two outs!
And, not only this, but the pitcher was Mariano Rivera, a pitcher whose blood-lust for pummeling batters with strikes had not wavered in the postseason for at least 2,129,760 minutes. The batter, meanwhile, was Tony Womack, who gets a hit less than 30.0 percent of the time. How improbable that he would hit a single at that moment!
And, not only this, but the Yankees were clearly the team with Destiny on their side. God had indicated His blessing to this team by allowing the players to make otherwise Impossible Comebacks as frequently as if they were popcorn.
But, bruised and bloody as they were, the Arizona Diamondbacks were not giving up. The Yankees did not win, and therefore were not able to avenge the Taliban for its hurtful actions on Sept. 11. New Yorkers will thus have to wait a few months longer before their lives can return to normal.
However, in the other city attacked on Sept. 11, Washington, D.C., God was actively seeking to revive the spirit of the people last week. After months of speculation and rumors, He’s donned a Washington Wizards uniform in His Second Coming-back. And, in the face of a groundswell of doubt, He’s led them to a 2-2 record.
Truly, there’s no one who can dribble and throw an inflated rubber sphere better than MJ. Ever. Period.
Hero — “one who shows great courage” — is too trite a word for Him. Every player in the NBA demonstrates their incredible fortitude every night they walk onto the court. “Legend” is still not enough, nor is “Incarnation.”
No, “Supreme Deity” is the only name for Him. He has carried and fulfilled too many huge hopes on His shoulders to be called otherwise.
And so, the shaken, anxious District of Columbia has turned its eyes to Him, praying that He can restore peace and order. We’re all wondering: Can He save the Washington Wizards? Can He save Washington? Can He save us?
We’d certainly like to hope so. He and others have already saved us from having to pay attention.
What else can we hope for?
Peter Stair is a junior majoring in human ecology. In defiance of natural law, he gave this column 110 percent. He couldn’t have done it without Michael Jordan. Please e-mail him if you enjoy bread and circus at pstair@stanford.edu.
November 6, 2001
By Peter Stair
Three seemingly unrelated events happened last week:
First, a study was released showing that the amount students are willing to pay (and that universities have the courage to charge) for a college certification continues to increase faster than inflation.
Second, another wealthy guy has made another outrageously large, record-setting, hundreds-of-millions-of-dollars donation to an already wealthy and expensive university. This time it was $600 million and the university was Cal Tech. Last time it was more than $400 million and the university was Stanford.
Third, last Tuesday, a number of homeless people and advocates stopped at Stanford on their march from San Jose to San Francisco. They told us how difficult it has been for them to get proper health care or education for their children and how impossible it has been for them to compete with Silicon Valley millionaires for housing. They asked for “compassion” from an uncharitable economic system.
This is a column not so much about these three events, but rather about the absurd world in which they would happen, and then be considered separately.
But, I must note that last week was also a truly phenomenal week in the world of sports. Especially in times like these, how can I avoid remarking on the Stanford football team?
Now I know many people have already written many fine sports columns, and these columnists are often both observant and lyrical. But it wouldn’t right for me to stay quiet.
Why? Because I learned something important over the weekend:
After an incident in the kitchen, I realized that I bleed. I bleed Red. A Red that looks suspiciously like Cardinal Red.
And, man oh man, was I bleeding after the Card’s exceedingly painful loss to Washington this week.
Truly, we were all suffering as we saw our Stanford team-mates writhing in agony and blood on the field last Saturday after the Huskies scorched us, 42-28.
It was a miserable sight.
It was the site of a Great Power falling, a bloody moment we will probably never forget. Before our eyes, we saw it happening, the Stanford Cardinal — a team that could have Won It All — falling from the ninth-and-two-thirds best team in the country to the 15th-and-one-third best team.
Our loss to Washington, to put it simply, was nothing less than totally devastating.
At times like these it’s important to have a little perspective. We can take walks and call relatives and remember that we will all die eventually. But, perhaps most importantly, we can remember the bottom line: Stanford football still has a bright future.
To put it in other words, if Stanford were a city-state, and our football team were our army, we could expect many years of bloody conquest and pillaging. And, when we are powerful again, we can remember this loss.
Just as Cato once said, “remember Carthage,” we can say, “remember the University of Washington.”
Speaking of remembering, though, will anyone forget how God dramatically turned against the Yankees this weekend?
How ironic! The Team of Destiny failed to win the Series That Everyone Will Talk About, Forever.
It all came down to the blood-filled ninth inning. Actually, it was not just the ninth inning, it was also the ninth inning of the seventh game. And not only did it come down to the ninth inning of the seventh game, but it also came down to the last two outs. The last two outs!
And, not only this, but the pitcher was Mariano Rivera, a pitcher whose blood-lust for pummeling batters with strikes had not wavered in the postseason for at least 2,129,760 minutes. The batter, meanwhile, was Tony Womack, who gets a hit less than 30.0 percent of the time. How improbable that he would hit a single at that moment!
And, not only this, but the Yankees were clearly the team with Destiny on their side. God had indicated His blessing to this team by allowing the players to make otherwise Impossible Comebacks as frequently as if they were popcorn.
But, bruised and bloody as they were, the Arizona Diamondbacks were not giving up. The Yankees did not win, and therefore were not able to avenge the Taliban for its hurtful actions on Sept. 11. New Yorkers will thus have to wait a few months longer before their lives can return to normal.
However, in the other city attacked on Sept. 11, Washington, D.C., God was actively seeking to revive the spirit of the people last week. After months of speculation and rumors, He’s donned a Washington Wizards uniform in His Second Coming-back. And, in the face of a groundswell of doubt, He’s led them to a 2-2 record.
Truly, there’s no one who can dribble and throw an inflated rubber sphere better than MJ. Ever. Period.
Hero — “one who shows great courage” — is too trite a word for Him. Every player in the NBA demonstrates their incredible fortitude every night they walk onto the court. “Legend” is still not enough, nor is “Incarnation.”
No, “Supreme Deity” is the only name for Him. He has carried and fulfilled too many huge hopes on His shoulders to be called otherwise.
And so, the shaken, anxious District of Columbia has turned its eyes to Him, praying that He can restore peace and order. We’re all wondering: Can He save the Washington Wizards? Can He save Washington? Can He save us?
We’d certainly like to hope so. He and others have already saved us from having to pay attention.
What else can we hope for?
Peter Stair is a junior majoring in human ecology. In defiance of natural law, he gave this column 110 percent. He couldn’t have done it without Michael Jordan. Please e-mail him if you enjoy bread and circus at pstair@stanford.edu.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)